Media Release 
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: 
 
Climate Minister briefed with unsubstantiated 
assumptions 
 
Not all Australians believe in catastrophic climate change, and most Australians would like 
to believe their Minister responsible for Climate Change was given factual briefings by 
balanced scientists within his department said Alex Stuart, chairman of the Australian 
Environment Foundation. 
 
The red book briefing on climate change prepared by the Department of Climate Change 
and Energy Efficiency for incoming minister Greg Combet, obtained by a newspaper under 
Freedom of Information 
law, is a mountain of misinformed speculation built on beliefs and 
faith said Mr Stuart.  
 
Stuart continued, As guidance intended for an incoming minister, this red book briefing fails 
completely.  Its apparently based on unsubstantiated assumptions, borrowed from 
discredited IPCC reports, not observational evidence based on research outcomes.   
The 
briefing is absurdly alarmist, when it should be careful and considered.   
 
The briefing apparently takes as fact issues such as catastrophic sea level rises, which are 
based only on scenarios, and proposes actions based on suppositions that have no proven 
basis. 
 
Stuarts comments came in the context of a mounting storm of protest over rising prices for 
electricity 
triggered by unworkable green programs, which are now seen to be intolerably 
expensive. Rising community anxiety coincides with mounting concerns over alarmist bias 
within the ministers department and the governments uncritical reliance on IPCC reports.   
 
Its time for state and federal governments to re-think their entire list of climate-related 
policies, to make sure theyre based on what is actually known. 
 
Its time this countrys 
climate policies were based on facts and evidence, not beliefs and faith said Mr Stuart.  
 
- 
ENDS - 
 
AEF Chairman:  Alex Stuart 0448-807-178 
AEF Executive Director:  Max Rheese 0428-621-320 
 
The Australian Environment Foundation (AEF) is a not-for-profit, membership-based 
environment organisation with no political affiliation.  It is a different kind of environment 
group, caring for both Australia & Australians, on the basis of facts and evidence.  Many of 
our members are practical environmentalists  people who actively use and also care for the 
environment.  We accept that environmental protection and sustainable resource use are 
generally compatible. For more information about the AEF visit www.aefweb.info  
October 31st 2010